This is a research that I have carried and forward on my blog. This research is about the media coverage that the period of sikh militancy ( 1984 – 1995) in India received. I will update this post as and when I have anything further to write. One should know that the period of Sikh militancy was one of the darkest periods in Indian history, the effects of which are felt till even today in India and abroad. The research is as follows:
ABSTRACT
Consequent to the 9/11 attacks and the subsequent war on terror, the historical accounts of religion based terrorism and the causative factors are becoming a subject of interest especially to media and political scholars. With the advancement of technology, influence of media has grown exponentially reifying the media’s strong and cultural impact upon society.
After the 9/11 attacks and the subsequent war on terror now being fought in Asia, it does inspire one to look at things in more detail, as to why does religion based terrorism occur and what are the factors visible and invisible that go in creating and sustaining it. The war on terror is fought in Asia and Pakistan is one of the important partners of the western forces fighting there. It is to be noted that until 1947 Pakistan was a part of India which was divided on the basis of religion. Thus this study set out to study the media coverage of religious divides in India. Often religious divides in India which is a multi- religious and multi- lingual country lead to violent clashes. Some have taken the form of militant activity as well. Sikh militancy of the eighties and the nineties is one such case.
With the intention to explore how the British media represents religious divides in India, this study made the Sikh militancy a case study. The coverage is analysed in one British Newspaper, namely The Times (London).
The results of the study show that key elements and events of the Sikh militancy received in depth coverage during the period under review (i.e. 1984-1995). They also provide engaging information on the sources which made the news during the period as well as the various contexts in which the news was reported.
CHAPTER – 1
INTRODUCTION
This research focuses on the coverage of religious divides in India by the British media – making Sikh militancy a case study. Within this context, other elements like media analysis of the political, economic, religious and cultural issues that had been influenced and affected by the Sikh militancy were also reviewed.
In reference to the works of Foucault, a 20th century French philosopher, sociologist and historian, Carrette (1999: p33) states that:
” Foucault’s work demonstrates a culture cannot understand itself without first understanding its implicit connection and development within the constructs of religious belief and practice. Contemporary culture is born out of religious traditions and the conditions of our knowledge are therefore embedded in religious discourse. The so-called secular space is itself a hybrid of past religious traditions, and in order to understand contemporary culture Foucault recognised (and was fascinated by) the religious influences upon thought and practice.”
Chase (2006) states, religious beliefs of a community or society play an important part in influencing its lifestyle. The thinking pattern of a society, the general state or habit of the mind of its inhabitants, their intellectual and moral development, their material and spiritual way of life, the practice and rituals followed; all of which determine its culture largely depend on its religious beliefs. Thus culture may be more properly understood as a ‘way of life’ (Chase, 2006). Culture based on religious beliefs gives a group or society its distinct identity and in a bid to preserve the same, man has engaged in violent conflicts all through history, which can be called religious fights or divides.
Background
Punjab is a state which is situated at the border between India and Pakistan. Pakistan is now an ally of the west in its war against terror. Hansen (2002) highlights that the Partition of Punjab which took place at the time when India got its independence in August 1947 from the British, constituted a humanitarian catastrophe with an estimated death toll of half a million people and around 14 million people getting displaced. The unprecedented violence after the partition was not a sudden wave of anger and madness that erupted. It was anticipated by the colonial rulers themselves and the communal organizations that had embarked upon assembling and training private armies. The other phase of violence in Punjab was through the eighties and unto the middle of the nineties which covers the period under review for this study. (Khan, 2007)
According to Khan (2007), Aggarwal & Aggarwal (1992), before India got its independence from the British in the year 1947, the Sikhs wanted a country of their own based on their religious beliefs. In 1946, the Sikhs declared a nation based on the tenets of Sikh religion and called for the creation of a Sikh state called Khalistan. Thereafter they proposed the union of the Sikhs in Pakistan. However the British preferred for the partition of India into two states i.e. India and Pakistan. While Jawaharlal Nehru (who then became the first Prime Minister of India) set up security for Sikhs in Indian future, the provisional government of Punjab was formed by a coalition of Muslims and Sikhs. However the Sikh massacres of Muslims that followed led to the annulling of the provisional government of Punjab. Sikhs then fled to India en masse and the British imposed partition of the country, which was endorsed on August 15, 1947.
Jodhka (2001) points out that, Punjab had done quite well economically during the post – independence period. The prosperity that was brought in Punjab by the green revolution during the 1960’s and 1970’s made it the most prosperous state in India with the highest per capita income in the 1980- 81 period. At the time, it also had one of the lowest proportions of the population living below the poverty line in the country. Not surprisingly, therefore, the rise of a secessionist movement in the state was a puzzle for many.
Significance and Scope of study
This study was designed to analyse how the British media presented religious divides in India, making Sikh militancy a case study. It tried to analyse the coverage of the highlighted issues from the British point of view, considering the fact that India a multi- religious country is a part of the commonwealth group of countries and was divided after its independence on the basis of religion.
India a multi- religious, multi- cultural country is situated in South Asia and has the second largest population in the world. The population of India is divided primarily into followers of eight religions. The chief among them are the followers of Hinduism, Islam, Christianity or Sikhism. In recent times however, there have been large scale riots due to the growing divide between people belonging to different communities, resulting in fatal loss of life and property.
The bomb blasts, shooting and hostage taking which took place in Mumbai in November 2008 sent alarm bells ringing throughout the world. This generated widespread concern as reports had confirmed that the men involved in these incidences came from Pakistan, its neighbouring country. Co-incidentally Pakistan also happens to be a partner of the US in its fight against terrorism. Hence religious divides in India and its implications on the rest of the world is arguably one of the most important issues today. The religious disturbances which occur in India do affect its neighbour Pakistan, which is an ally of the Western forces fighting in Afghanistan. Thus an event in India affects the world politics in general (both in the Muslim and the Christian world).
Justification
Within this dissertation (i.e. the Literature review section) is an elaborate discussion on how the topic of religious divides in India has been treated in academic circles. Here I posit that the general focus of academic research lay on the Hindu – Muslim communal clashes specifically during the post – independence era and after the demolition of the disputed structure (a mosque) at Ayodhya in Uttar Pradesh in 1992.
Relative to these events, it would appear that the Sikh militancy of the eighties and the nineties which took place between the above two mentioned events and which formed an important part of the political and religious history of India did not get as much in-depth coverage. It was therefore a point of interest as these three major phases of communal events after India got its independence have played an important role in the formation of the domestic and foreign policy of India. This research project will contribute to the body of knowledge and illuminate key issues about the coverage received during the period under review.
Research Questions
- What elements of the Sikh Militancy received the most or the least coverage?
- What was the frequency of the coverage during the years under consideration i.e. between 1984 and 1995?
- In what context were the reports written and who were they primarily addressed to?
- What were the primary sources of the news during the Sikh militancy?
- How did the British media present the effect of the Sikh militancy on the foreign policy and relations of India?
- How did the British media analyse the effect of factors such as political, religious/ cultural and violence on the Sikh militancy?
Definition of key terms
The following are frequently used in this dissertation:
1) Sikhs: Five hundred years ago, Guru Nanak founded the Sikh religion in India. In the centuries that followed, three of Nanak’s nine successors met violent ends, and his people continued to battle hostile regimes.
2) Punjab: A state in India on the border with Pakistan. This state of Punjab was partitioned during the partition of India after the British gave Independence to India.
Summary of Methodology
Content Analysis was the method adopted to carry out the research. Considering the period under review was spread over a period of twelve years, this method was deemed to be most suitable for the research. Though interviews were initially considered as one of the research methods, they were found to be inconvenient as the research period was not only extensive but also the event locations were foreign i.e. based in India.
Dissertation Structure
Below is a summary of the various chapters in this dissertation:
- Literature Review: This section provides background information about religion as a shaper and a divider. It then proceeds to synthesize key literature on the relationship between religion, culture and politics. This information then leads us to details about the religions in India and the divides that prevail within them. This is followed by the explanation of the relationship between media and religion and the sources that make the news. The section concludes with the literature review on the media coverage of Sikh militancy.
- Methodology: To carry out the research, this study has employed Content Analysis as the method as it would be the best suited method for a research which analysis news coverage of events spread over a period of 12 years. For the research this study has selected The Times (London) Publication as it is broadly representative of the elite press in the UK, to analyse how the British media covers the religious divides in India, making Sikh militancy a case study. The chapter on methodology gives a detailed explanation about the method chosen.
- Findings and Results: In this section, the results of the findings of the study are presented and discussed. This section is divided into three chapters which tries to answer the above mentioned research questions in the light of the findings and discussions of the SPSS analysis. The three chapters present the findings of the SPSS analysis and a brief textual analysis of sample publications leading to the conclusion and reflection chapter.
- Conclusion and Reflection: This chapter concludes the dissertation and also contains a brief reflection on the author’s research experience.
****To be continued ****